From biscuits and gravy to holiday dinners, there’s nothing like a homemade biscuit. But if you’re still using a glass from your cupboard to cut out your biscuit, you might be missing out on some innovative ways to create the perfect biscuit shape.
Consider upgrading to a set of surprisingly multipurpose biscuit cutters. For instance, if you want a range of biscuit cutter sizes for tackling anything from donuts to ravioli, the 11-piece Ateco Plain Edge Round Cutters would be a great choice for you. Here are the best biscuit cutters to add to your kitchen.
What to know before you buy a biscuit cutter
What can you do with a biscuit cutter?
While a biscuit cutter may not sound like a kitchen multitasker, it can actually be used for puff pastry, savory dishes, cake decorating and more. With their sharp sides, biscuit cutters make excellent cookie cutters. Or, if you ever make your own pasta or dumplings, biscuit cutters can be used to cut out dough rounds for filling. You can cut out fondant shapes with biscuit cutters or use them as stamps and stencils to decorate a cake. Biscuit cutters can even help make homemade donuts — cut out the donut using a large round biscuit cutter, then use a smaller size to cut the hole from the middle.
The majority of biscuit cutters are made from stainless steel, which won’t warp, dent or corrode easily. Stainless steel biscuit cutters also feature sharp sides for clean and easy cutting. But good-quality stainless steel can be pricey, so if cost is a factor, consider biscuit cutters made from plastic. Plastic biscuit cutters are more affordable and generally safer for kids to use if they’re helping you in the kitchen. However, they don’t withstand heat well and they’re prone to cracking.
For most recipes, a biscuit cutter that makes biscuits measuring between 2-3 inches is all you need. However, for extra-large biscuits or foods like donuts, puff pastry, cookies or even burger patties, home cooks can find a use for biscuit cutters of almost any size. Many biscuit cutters come in a set of three or four in different sizes, in some cases up to 5 inches across.
Biscuit cutter features
Biscuit size range
Biscuit cutters are commonly purchased in nesting sets of three or more graduated sizes. Some even come with ten or more biscuit cutters in sizes starting at smaller than one inch. While at first a set like this may seem like way too many options, many cooks find having an assortment of graduated sizes make recipes easier and more precise.
Round biscuit cutters are the most popular shape, but squares are also common. You can even find biscuit cutters in unique shapes like hearts, stars or flowers, which can be used on anything from biscuits and cookies to fondant or even clay. Most biscuit cutters have straight edges, but some have ripple edges to add old-fashioned details to your baking.
Additional baking tools
Biscuit cutters are sometimes sold with extra equipment to up your baking game. Bundling your biscuit cutter with tools like a silicone baking mat, pastry cutter, bench scraper or stencils can save you money and expand your baking repertoire.
Handle or no handle?
Most biscuit cutters are simple, flat shapes, but some offer handles that arch over the cutter for an easier grip. Some of these handles are even made with ergonomic rubber grips. Standard flat cutters are typically the easiest to store, but even biscuit cutters with handles nest for more organized storage. If you make lots of biscuits or cookies, or if you have a condition that affects your finger strength, biscuit cutters with handles may be the best choice for you.
Biscuit cutter cost
Most sets of 3-5 stainless steel biscuit cutters cost between $10-$20. Sets of higher-end cutters made from patented materials or with ergonomic handles can cost between $25-$80. Plastic biscuit cutters come in sets of 5 or more and cost between $5-$12.
Biscuit cutter FAQ
How do you clean a biscuit cutter?
A. Many biscuit cutters are dishwasher-safe, but for those that aren't, wash them thoroughly with warm water and dish soap, using a dish brush to clean any remaining dough out of seams or handles. Let stainless steel biscuit cutters air-dry fully before putting them away to prevent rust.
Do I need a biscuit cutter?
A. If you're cutting out biscuits using a glass or can, you're probably not getting the tastiest possible biscuits — and if you're using a knife, you risk damaging your work surfaces or cutting yourself. When you cut out a biscuit with a glass, you press the top layer of dough down over the edges of the biscuit and it won't fully rise during baking. The sharp edges of biscuit cutters ensure there's no pinching so you get fluffy, satisfying biscuits.
Which biscuit cutter should I get?
Best of the best biscuit cutter
Ateco Plain Edge 11-Piece Round Cutters Set: available at Amazon
Our take: With 11 size options, this set of stainless steel biscuit cutters from a respected baking brand offers a size for every recipe.
What we like: These biscuit cutters range in size from 3/4 inches up to 3 5/8 inches. Their rolled edges help make the grip safer and more comfortable. The biscuit cutters nest in the included tin for easy storage.
What we dislike: Some users found the construction somewhat flimsy, despite the brand's reputation. They may not be tall enough for thicker doughs. The cutters aren't labeled, which can make selecting the right size tricky.
Best bang for your buck biscuit cutter
RSVP International Endurance Round Biscuit Cutters: available at Amazon
Our take: This set of four nesting biscuit cutters has curved handles for comfortable cutting.
What we like: The cutters range from 1 1/2 inches up to 2 3/4 inches and are 3 1/4 inches tall including the handle, so they can cut through thick biscuit dough easily. The stainless steel construction feels sturdy and resists bending or warping.
What we dislike: Some users had issues with the handles falling off after only a few uses. The manufacturer recommends hand-washing them instead of using the dishwasher.
Honorable mention biscuit cutter
HULISEN Stainless Steel Pastry Scraper, Dough Blender and Biscuit Cutter Set: available at Amazon
Our take: Great for gifts, this set includes five biscuit cutters along with a bench scraper and a pastry blender.
What we like: The five biscuit cutters have handles and range from 1 3/4 inches up to 3 1/4 inches. The bench scraper and the dough blender have ergonomic rubber handles. All the pieces are dishwasher-safe and the cutters are labeled with their sizes.
What we dislike: Some users had concerns about durability and quality control.
Laura Duerr is a writer for BestReviews. BestReviews is a product review company with a singular mission: to help simplify your purchasing decisions and save you time and money.
BestReviews spends thousands of hours researching, analyzing and testing products to recommend the best picks for most consumers. BestReviews and its newspaper partners may earn a commission if you purchase a product through one of our links.
Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.